How To Sharpen Kitchen Knife With Whetstone: Expert Guide

Can you sharpen a kitchen knife with a whetstone? Yes, you absolutely can, and it’s the best way to achieve a truly sharp edge. This guide will walk you through the entire process of whetstone sharpening, from choosing the right stones to mastering the techniques. Sharpening your kitchen knives with a whetstone might seem daunting at first, but with practice, it becomes a simple and rewarding skill, essential for any home cook who values precision and safety in the kitchen. A sharp knife not only makes food preparation easier and more enjoyable but also reduces the risk of accidents.

Image Source: www.thespruceeats.com

Deciphering Whetstone Types

Before we dive into the sharpening process, let’s talk about the tools. The heart of whetstone sharpening is, of course, the whetstone itself. There’s a variety of whetstone types available, each with its own purpose and characteristics.

Natural vs. Synthetic Whetstones

Natural Whetstones: These are stones quarried from the earth, often from specific regions known for their high-quality sharpening properties. They are prized for their ability to create incredibly fine edges and a pleasant feel during sharpening. However, they can be expensive and require more maintenance.
Synthetic Whetstones: These are man-made stones, typically composed of abrasive particles (like aluminum oxide or silicon carbide) bonded together. They are more readily available, often more affordable, and their grit consistency is predictable. For most home cooks, synthetic whetstones are an excellent choice.

Water Stones vs. Oil Stones

Water Stones: These are the most common type of whetstone used for kitchen knives. They require soaking in water before use (hence the name wet sharpening stone). The water acts as a lubricant, flushing away metal particles and creating a slurry that aids in the sharpening process. They typically cut faster and produce a finer edge than oil stones.
Oil Stones: These stones use oil as a lubricant. They tend to cut more slowly than water stones but can achieve very sharp edges. Some older knives or those with specific steel types might benefit from oil stones, but for most modern kitchen knives, water stones are preferred.

The Importance of Grit Progression

The secret to a truly sharp knife lies in grit progression. Whetstones are categorized by their grit number, which indicates the coarseness or fineness of the abrasive particles. A higher grit number means finer particles and a smoother finish. You’ll typically start with a coarser grit to repair damage or set an edge, then move to progressively finer grits to refine and polish the edge.

Common Grit Ranges and Their Uses

Coarse Grit (100-400): These stones are for repairing chips, reshaping a damaged edge, or sharpening very dull knives. They remove metal quickly.
Medium Grit (500-1000): This is the workhorse grit. It’s used for general sharpening and re-establishing a good edge after the coarse stone.
Fine Grit (1000-3000): These stones are for refining the edge, making it sharper and smoother. They remove the burr left by coarser stones.
Extra Fine Grit (4000-8000+): These ultra-fine stones are for polishing the edge to a razor-sharp, mirror-like finish. They are excellent for achieving the highest level of sharpness for delicate tasks.

Recommended Whetstone Kit for Kitchen Knives

For most home cooks, a three-stone setup is ideal:

Medium Grit (around 1000): For general sharpening.
Fine Grit (around 3000): For refining the edge.
Extra Fine Grit (around 6000): For polishing and achieving extreme sharpness.

You can find combination stones that have two different grits on either side, which can be a space and cost-saving option.

Preparing Your Whetstone for Sharpening

Proper preparation of your wet sharpening stone is crucial for effective whetstone sharpening.

Soaking Water Stones

Most water stones need to be soaked in water before use. The soaking time can vary depending on the stone, but generally:

Soaking Stones: Submerge the whetstone in a container of water until it stops releasing air bubbles. This usually takes 5-15 minutes. Some synthetic stones are “splash-and-go” and only require a quick splash of water on the surface. Always check the manufacturer’s instructions for your specific stones.
Maintaining Moisture: During sharpening, keep the surface of the stone wet. Periodically splash more water on it to keep the slurry forming and prevent the stone from drying out.

Setting Up Your Sharpening Station

A stable surface is paramount. You don’t want your stone or knife to slip during the sharpening process.

Stone Holder: Use a whetstone holder or a damp cloth placed underneath the stone to prevent it from sliding.
Workspace: Choose a well-lit area where you can comfortably place your stone and work on your knife.

Mastering the Knife Sharpening Angle

Achieving the correct knife sharpening angle is perhaps the most critical aspect of whetstone sharpening. The angle determines how the edge is formed.

What is the Correct Knife Sharpening Angle?

The ideal knife sharpening angle for kitchen knives typically falls between 15 and 20 degrees per side.

European/American Knives: Usually benefit from an angle of 20 degrees per side.
Japanese Knives: Often have thinner blades and are designed for a steeper angle, typically 15 degrees per side.

Some knives might have a “micro-bevel” or “secondary bevel,” which is a very small, steeper angle at the very edge, enhancing durability and sharpness. When sharpening, you are essentially replicating the existing angle of the blade’s bevel.

Tools to Help Maintain the Angle

Maintaining a consistent angle can be challenging for beginners. Several tools can assist:

Angle Guides: These small clips attach to the spine of your knife, helping to guide your hand and maintain a consistent angle.
Sharpening Systems: Some systems come with adjustable guides and fixtures that hold the knife at a precise angle.

Visualizing the Angle

A simple way to visualize the angle:

Place the knife flat on the stone.
Lift the spine of the knife until the edge makes contact.
For a 20-degree angle, imagine lifting the spine about one-third the width of your index finger.
For a 15-degree angle, lift the spine about one-quarter the width of your index finger.

Practice this with your eye before you even start sharpening.

Step-by-Step Whetstone Sharpening Techniques

Now, let’s get to the actual sharpening. This is where sharpening techniques come into play.

Step 1: Sharpening on the Coarse or Medium Grit Stone

Start with your coarsest (or medium grit if your knife isn’t very dull) wet sharpening stone.

Positioning: Place the whetstone on its holder or a damp cloth. Ensure it’s stable.
Grip: Hold the knife firmly with your dominant hand on the handle. Place the fingers of your non-dominant hand flat on the blade near the edge, applying gentle pressure.
Initial Stroke: Lay the blade flat on the stone. Lift the spine to achieve your desired knife sharpening angle (e.g., 15-20 degrees).
Sharpening Motion: Push the knife forward across the stone, as if you were trying to slice a thin layer off the stone. Maintain the angle and apply consistent, moderate pressure. As you reach the end of the stone, curve the knife slightly to bring the heel of the blade into contact with the stone.
Drawing Stroke: As you pull the knife back, maintain the angle and apply lighter pressure. Focus on letting the stone do the work.
Repetition: Repeat this motion, working the entire length of the blade. The goal is to remove metal evenly along the edge.
Alternating Sides: Make a consistent number of strokes on one side of the blade, then flip the knife over and repeat the process on the other side. For general sharpening, aim for 10-20 strokes per side.
Checking for a Burr: A “burr” is a small, wire-like edge of metal that forms on the opposite side of the edge you are sharpening. You can feel for it by gently running your fingertip across the edge (away from the edge itself, from spine to cutting edge). Once you feel a burr along the entire length of the blade, you’ve sharpened that side sufficiently.

Step 2: Refining on the Fine Grit Stone

Once you’ve established an edge on the coarser stone and have a burr on both sides, move to your finer grit stone.

Repeat the Process: Follow the exact same motions as with the coarser stone.
Lighter Pressure: Use lighter pressure on finer grit stones. The goal here is to refine the edge, not remove a lot of material.
Focus on Burr Removal: Continue sharpening, alternating sides, until the burr is removed and replaced by a finer, less noticeable burr. You might feel the burr diminish with each pass.
Fewer Strokes: You’ll need fewer strokes on the finer grit. 5-10 strokes per side are often enough.

Step 3: Polishing on the Extra Fine Grit Stone (Optional but Recommended)

For a truly razor-sharp edge, use your extra-fine grit stone.

Very Light Pressure: Use extremely light pressure on this stone.
Refined Strokes: Make slow, deliberate strokes, alternating sides. The goal is to polish the very apex of the edge.
Deburring Strokes: Finish with a few very light “deburring” strokes, alternating sides, with almost no pressure, lifting the spine slightly with each stroke. This helps to remove any microscopic burr remaining.

Removing the Burr and Testing for Sharpness

The burr needs to be removed for a clean, sharp edge.

How to Remove the Burr

Alternating Strokes: Light, alternating strokes on progressively finer stones help to break off and refine the burr.
Stropping: Some people use leather strops (often with a polishing compound) after the finest stone to remove the last vestiges of the burr and align the edge. While not strictly whetstone sharpening, it’s a common follow-up.
Very Light Strokes: A few very light, alternating strokes on the sharpening stone, with the spine slightly lifted, can also effectively remove the burr.

Testing Your Knife’s Sharpness

The Paper Test: The most common test. Hold a piece of printer paper vertically and try to slice through it with the knife. A sharp knife should slice through the paper smoothly and without tearing or snagging.
The Tomato Test: A sharp knife will easily slice through the skin of a tomato without crushing it.
The Arm Hair Test: (Use with extreme caution and only on a truly razor-sharp edge you’ve achieved.) A very sharp knife can shave the hair off your arm. This is a professional-level test and not recommended for beginners.

Maintaining Your Sharp Knives: Beyond Sharpening

Knife maintenance is an ongoing process. Sharpening isn’t a one-time event; regular care will keep your knives performing at their best.

Honing vs. Sharpening

It’s important to distinguish between sharpening and honing.

Sharpening: This process actually removes metal to create a new, sharp edge. It’s done with whetstones, diamond stones, or other abrasive tools.
Honing: This process realigns a slightly bent or rolled-over edge back into its proper position. It doesn’t remove significant amounts of metal. A honing rod (often called a sharpening steel) is used for this.

When to Use a Honing Rod

You should hone your knives regularly, often before each use or every few uses, depending on how much you use them.

How to Use a Honing Rod: Hold the honing rod vertically or horizontally. Place the heel of the knife on the rod at the desired knife sharpening angle (usually the same angle you sharpen at, around 15-20 degrees). Draw the knife down the rod, maintaining the angle, from heel to tip. Repeat on the other side. Aim for 5-10 strokes per side.

Proper Knife Care Practices

Washing: Always wash your knives by hand with warm, soapy water. Never put them in the dishwasher. Dishwasher detergents are harsh, and the tumbling action can dull the blade and damage the handle.
Drying: Dry your knives immediately after washing to prevent rust, especially for carbon steel knives.
Storage: Store your knives properly to protect the edge and prevent accidents. Use a knife block, magnetic strip, or blade guards. Avoid tossing them loosely into a drawer.
Cutting Surface: Use appropriate cutting boards. Wood or high-quality plastic boards are best. Avoid glass, ceramic, or stone surfaces, which will quickly dull your knives.

Troubleshooting Common Whetstone Sharpening Issues

Even with the best intentions, you might encounter some common problems.

Uneven Sharpening

Cause: Inconsistent angle, not working the entire length of the blade.
Solution: Focus on maintaining a consistent angle. Use an angle guide if needed. Ensure you are moving the knife across the entire surface of the stone and working from heel to tip on both sides.

Not Sharp Enough

Cause: Not enough sharpening strokes, using too fine a grit too soon, failure to remove the burr.
Solution: Be patient and make enough strokes on each grit. Ensure you can feel a burr before moving to the next stone. Make sure you’ve effectively removed the burr.

The Edge is Rough or Chipped

Cause: Too much pressure, using a very coarse stone for too long, or a damaged stone.
Solution: Use lighter pressure on finer grits. If the edge is significantly chipped, you might need to start with a coarser grit to reshape it, then work your way up. Check your stone for damage.

Stone Loading

Cause: Metal filings and slurry building up on the stone’s surface, reducing its cutting ability.
Solution: Keep the stone wet with plenty of water. Rinse the stone periodically during sharpening. After use, clean the stone thoroughly with water and a brush. Some stones might require “lapping” (flattening) if they become dished out.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: How often should I sharpen my kitchen knives?
A1: This depends on your usage. For daily home use, sharpening every 1-3 months is often sufficient. If you notice your knife is no longer slicing efficiently, it’s time to sharpen. Honing should be done much more frequently, perhaps before each use.

Q2: What is sharpening oil and do I need it?
A2: Sharpening oil is a lubricant used with oil stones. If you are using water stones, you will use water, not oil. For oil stones, a light honing oil is typically recommended to help flush away debris.

Q3: Can I use my sharpening steel as a whetstone?
A3: No, a sharpening steel or honing rod is for honing, not sharpening. It realigns the edge. A whetstone removes metal to create a new edge.

Q4: How do I flatten my whetstone if it gets dished out?
A4: Dishing occurs when the center of the stone wears down faster than the edges. To flatten it, you can use a lapping stone, a piece of silicon carbide sandpaper on a flat surface (like a piece of glass), or rub two whetstones together. This process is called lapping.

Q5: What grit should I start with if my knife is not very dull?
A5: If your knife is only slightly dull, you can often skip the coarse grit and start with a medium grit stone (around 1000 grit) to reset the edge, then move to finer grits for refinement.

Q6: Is it better to use a coarse or fine grit stone first?
A6: You always start with the coarsest grit necessary for the task. If your knife is chipped or very dull, start with a coarse grit (e.g., 400). If it’s just a bit dull, you can start with a medium grit (e.g., 1000). You then progress to finer grits.

Q7: How do I sharpen a serrated knife with a whetstone?
A7: Sharpening serrated knives is different. You typically need a specialized sharpening rod or a small ceramic rod that fits the gullets (the valleys between the serrations). You’ll sharpen each serration individually at its original angle. This is a more advanced technique.

Q8: Do I need a different sharpening angle for different types of knives?
A8: Yes, as mentioned, European/American knives usually have a 20-degree angle, while Japanese knives often have a 15-degree angle. Always try to match the existing angle of your knife’s bevel.

By following these detailed steps and practicing consistently, you’ll soon be able to sharpen your kitchen knives to a professional-level sharpness. This skill not only enhances your cooking experience but also prolongs the life and performance of your valuable kitchen tools. Happy sharpening!